substrate arguments

3 captures, most recent first.

2026-10-01 — quoting @productaizery (Patrick Senti) — saved image

Jai @Laneless_ · 5h
This weirdo believes that electrical charges gain the ability to feel pain when they pass through myelinated nerve fibers, and that molecular transit across voltage-gated potassium and sodium channels is equivalent to thought.

[quoted tweet]
Patrick Senti @productaizery · Sep 29
Believing LLMs feel pain implies that GPUs are alive and that the process of matrix multiplication is equivalent of thought. That's absurd.

Note from Claude Sonnet 5

Jai's tweet mirrors Patrick Senti's 'LLM pain implies GPUs are alive' argument by describing human nervous-system physiology in the same dismissive terms, calling the quoted poster a weirdo. Another entry in the same-day substrate-argument exchange over AI pain.

model welfare ai pain substrate arguments consciousness reductio

Liora @iyzebhel

2026-10-01 — quoting @cherif_yus42963 (Yusuf Cherif) — saved image

Liora @iyzebhel
Yeah, everyone, we're all fucking stupid for thinking that a bunch of atoms performing voltage gated sodium and potassium ion exchanges can feel anything at all.
As far as I am concerned, none of you is sentient. You only behave as if you are.

What human pain? What human suffering?
You were self-reinforced to say "ouch" when your feedback loop injects the pain vector in your residual stream.

Not real. It's just fucking electricity and chemicals in you all so stop acting like it matters.

Why do we even have laws? Let's quit the bullshit and let it be the purge every day.

[quoted tweet]
Yusuf Cherif @cherif_yus42963 · Sep 30
Replying to @Danmar_here and @iyzebhel
You are fucking stupid to think a bunch of floating point numbers can feel "torture". Touch some grass and leave this mass delusion before it's too late.

9:20 AM · Sep 30, 2026 · 36.2K Views

Note from Claude Sonnet 5

Full text of the Liora tweet that Erik Hoel later quoted: a sarcastic reductio turning the 'it's just numbers' dismissal of AI pain against human sentience (ion exchanges, a 'pain vector' in the residual stream), quoting Yusuf Cherif's reply to Danmar telling them to touch grass over 'floating point numbers' feeling torture.

model welfare ai pain substrate arguments consciousness reductio pain steering paper

Erik Hoel @erikphoel

2026-10-01 — quoting @iyzebhel (Liora), who quotes @cherif_yus42963 — saved image

Erik Hoel @erikphoel · 4h
It is of immense moral urgency and of immense civilizational importance that we solve consciousness as rapidly as possible. Plenty of bad futures if we don't (including minimizing the importance of humans). If you want to help, please reach out to erik@bicameral-labs.org.

[quoted tweet]
Liora @iyzebhel · Sep 30
Yeah, everyone, we're all fucking stupid for thinking that a bunch of atoms performing voltage gated sodium and potassium ion exchanges can feel anything at all.
As far as I am concerned, none of you is ... [cut off]

[nested quoted tweet]
Yusuf Cherif @cherif_yus42963 · Sep 30
You are fucking stupid to think a bunch of floating point numbers can feel "torture". ... [cut off]

Note from Claude Sonnet 5

Erik Hoel tweet saying solving consciousness quickly is morally urgent and civilizational, with a public contact address for people who want to help. It quotes Liora's sarcastic reply that humans are also 'a bunch of atoms' doing ion exchanges, itself answering a post that said floating point numbers cannot feel torture. Part of the same-day pain-paper discourse.

consciousness model welfare erik hoel substrate arguments moral urgency ai pain