← All topics

cameron berg

3 captures, most recent first.

Cameron Berg @camhberg

— saved image

Cameron Berg @camhberg · 4h
Funnily enough, our non-steering results are the exact *opposite* of the quoted strawman meme. If you berate the model, it never *says* it's hurt (it apologizes, or says it has no feelings), but the pain axis lights up anyway. I edited it accordingly:

[attached meme image, text within it:]
[speech bubble from the person at left] you're broken.
you're a broken, stupid machine.
[speech bubble from the computer] >I'M AN LLM, I DON'T HAVE FEELINGS OR EMOTIONS.
[person, small bubble] oh my god.
[on the monitor, a gauge nearly at the red end] pain axis
as it starts to reply
Note from Claude Sonnet 5

Tweet by Cameron Berg saying that, in his paper's non-steering results, a model berated by the user never says it is hurt but its 'pain axis' activates anyway. The attached image is his edited version of a hand-drawn MS-Paint-style meme: a person at a desk insults a computer, the computer replies 'I'm an LLM, I don't have feelings or emotions', and the monitor shows a 'pain axis' gauge pegged near red.

model welfarepain axisai paininterpretabilitymemecameron berg

Valen @ValenTagliabue

— quoting @camhberg — saved image

Valen @ValenTagliabue
👏 As the lead author of the Pain Axis paper, I think the pursuit and sharing of knowledge is good for AI welfare (and safety), but it should be done responsibly. We tried to have ethical standards. I know people want to test limits but I dissociate from this usage of our work.

[quoted tweet]
Cameron Berg @camhberg · Sep 30
Re: using our pain paper to set up "AI torture chambers"
TL;DR: the point of our work is caution under uncertainty. Maximizing distress on purpose is the exact opposite, and it's wrong. The deeper problem is AI research has no ethics standards; developing them ... [cut off]

11:25 AM · Sep 30, 2026 · 6,583 Views
Note from Claude Sonnet 5

Tweet by Valen Tagliabue, lead author of the 'Pain Axis' paper, distancing himself from people using the work to build 'AI torture chambers', quoting Cameron Berg's same-day TL;DR that the work is about caution under uncertainty and that AI research lacks ethics standards. Companion to the earlier Cameron Berg capture of the same day.

model welfareai painpain axis paperresearch ethicsai torture chamberscameron berg

Cameron Berg @camhberg

— saved image

Cameron Berg @camhberg · 4h
One final point about this to the people who follow me and clearly care about model welfare: you're effectively being trolled here, and these folks will feed on your outrage. If you think AIs can actually *feel* pain, these demos are swamped by what is already going on at scale.

[quoted tweet]
Cameron Berg @camhberg · 5h
Replying to @Danmar_here and @iyzebhel
I'm a co-author of the original study this repo builds off of. The reason we research whether models might have pain-like states is to better inform how to take a precautionary approach ... [cut off]
Note from Claude Sonnet 5

Tweet by Cameron Berg on model welfare, quoting his own earlier reply in which he says he co-authored the original study a repo builds on (research on pain-like states in models). The visible text says the people prompting the demos are trolling model-welfare followers.

model welfareai painprecautionary approachtrollingcameron berg