← All topics

analogy

1 capture, most recent first.

Isaac King @IsaacKing314

quoting @pessimistsarchive newsletter

Isaac King @IsaacKing314: "Came across a neat summary of society's transition to using artificial ice in the mid to late 1800s." Quoted card: "The notion of 'manufacturing' ice through an industrial process likely felt similarly strange as lab grown meat feels today. A product of a natural process suddenly produced through scientific wizardry. In 1847 Gorrie would astonish guests at an event in Florida by serving wine cooled with artificial ice in the middle of summer - when ice was often scarce. Some scoffed at the notion - with The New York Daily Globe reportedly saying that same year: 'There is a Dr. Gorrie, a crank, down in Florida, who thinks he can make ice as good as God Almighty.'" 3:51 PM · Jul 1, 2025 · 5,817 Views [reply 5, retweet 17, like 174, bookmark 23] > QUOTED (Isaac King, 5h, embedded link card "The War on 'Artificial' Ice" from newsletter.pessimistsarchive.org): [image of an old newspaper ad headlined "Natural vs Machine Made Ice / NATURAL BETTER. WHY? / FREEZING.—Natural produces more cold air than Artificial Ice. Take 100 pounds Natural Ice, place thermometer in refrigerator—note readings, then try 100 pounds Artificial; watch thermometer; note readings, compare the two and see difference in degrees of cold obtained. Natural Ice free from zinc and other mineral impurities obtained from tanks in freezing machine made ice."] reply 0, retweet 0, like 22, views 678 Reply visible below: keysmashb... @keysmashb... · 24m: "Extremely cool"
Note from Claude Sonnet 5

A tweet about historical resistance to "artificial" (machine-made) ice in the 1800s, drawing an explicit analogy to present-day skepticism of lab-grown meat. Likely saved as a historical-analogy example for technology adoption / status-quo bias arguments, possibly relevant to AI-adoption or novel-technology-skepticism framing Nathan uses in his own writing.

twitterhistory-of-technologypessimists-archivetechnology-adoptionanalogylab-grown-meat